Space Industry and Business News  
BMD Focus: Barak dithered on Phalanx

The Vulcan Phalanx has proved itself repeatedly in combat in Iraq, so in these difficult times the U.S. Army very sensibly wants as many of them as it can get. Because Barak dithered for so many years, Israel is now at the back of the queue.
by Martin Sieff
Washington (UPI) May 6, 2009
Israeli Defense Minister Ehud Barak has finally bitten the bullet and announced that he is going to order Raytheon's Vulcan Phalanx super machine gun and radar system as a defense against very-short-range rockets threatening Israel from Hamas in the south and Hezbollah in the north. But he may have left it too late.

Barak could and should have ordered the Raytheon Vulcan Phalanxes with its 20mm Gatling super-gun during the more than two years that he was defense minister while the strongly pro-Israel Bush administration was in power; he would have had them by now. A sympathetic White House would have made sure the request was fast-tracked through the huge U.S. military procurement process. The guns fire 3,000 shells per minute and cost $25 million each.

However, now the very different Obama administration is in office, and new U.S. President Barack Obama appears headed for a head-on confrontation with Israel over his demand for a quick agreement with the Palestinians in the peace process and his refusal to approve any unilateral Israeli airstrikes against Iran's threatening nuclear development program. New Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu is scheduled to visit Obama in the White House on May 17 to discuss coordinating U.S. and Israeli policies on both those issues. Political insiders in Washington and Jerusalem agree that the meeting is not expected to be a relaxed or happy one.

Netanyahu and Barak, his old commander in Israel's elite Sayeret Matkal commando unit nearly 40 years ago, are both used to a world where for decades every U.S. administration has been eager to supply Israel's high-tech strategic wish lists as quickly as it possibly can.

The only time since 1980 that there has been any significant strain in U.S.-Israeli relations was when Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir infuriated President George Herbert Walker Bush and his secretary of state, James A. Baker III, by continuing to build and expand settlements on the West Bank and trying to get Congress to approve $10 billion, not in additional loans but in loan guarantees, at the same time. Bush successfully blocked the loan guarantees. Before that, Bush and his predecessor, President Ronald Reagan, were very supportive of Israel's security agenda and military needs, and so were Democratic President Bill Clinton and Republican President George W. Bush after them.

That is still the case. But if Netanyahu and Barak approve Israeli airstrikes against Iran's nuclear facilities, Obama could retaliate by freezing or just slowing down the sale of weapons systems and important technology to Israel. For all the fame and successful export sales of the Israeli arms industry, U.S. cooperation in research and development, and in production, remains the critical resource that allows a tiny country of 6 million people to remain a world player in weapons development and exports.

Had Barak ordered the Vulcan Phalanx two and a half years ago, he would probably have received some of them by now. But Obama is now determined to expand the U.S. military presence in Afghanistan. Also, the Sunni insurgency in Iraq is heating up again in anticipation of the massive troop-level reductions Obama has promised.

The Vulcan Phalanx has proved itself repeatedly in combat in Iraq, so in these difficult times the U.S. Army very sensibly wants as many of them as it can get. Because Barak dithered for so many years, Israel is now at the back of the queue.

Respected Israeli analyst Yossi Melman, who has provided unequaled cutting-edge coverage of the controversy, wrote in Haaretz last month that Barak's decision "should have been made more than two years ago. This is a lifesaving system that is proving itself in the American military operations in Afghanistan and Iraq."

If it were not for Melman and Haaretz, the Israeli public would have been kept in the dark for years about the potential availability of the Vulcan Phalanx and the problems surrounding Israel's own long-delayed and still troubled Rafael Iron Dome interceptor system against very-short-range missiles. In the U.S. media, the issue has only been consistently covered by United Press International.

Melman reported in Haaretz last month that Barak and his Defense Ministry have already appealed in vain both to the U.S. Department of Defense and to Raytheon Co. to purchase the Vulcan Phalanx system. But the demand for the system is so great that current orders are committed to the U.S. armed forces for years to come.

Haaretz reported that Barak plans to visit Washington next month and then go over the heads of the Pentagon and Raytheon by making his case directly to U.S. Secretary of Defense Robert Gates.

However, Barak, who repeatedly showed in his 1999-2001 stint as Israeli prime minister that he had a tin ear for politics and diplomacy, will be visiting the U.S. capital just a couple of weeks after his boss Netanyahu. If Netanyahu doesn't play ball with Obama on the peace process and Iran, then Gates is unlikely to go out of his way to secure the Raytheon Phalanx system, including its Gatling guns, for Israel.

Share This Article With Planet Earth
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit
YahooMyWebYahooMyWeb GoogleGoogle FacebookFacebook



Related Links
Learn about missile defense at SpaceWar.com
Learn about nuclear weapons doctrine and defense at SpaceWar.com
All about missiles at SpaceWar.com
Learn about the Superpowers of the 21st Century at SpaceWar.com



Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News


BMD Watch: Roketsan lands Patriot deal
Washington (UPI) May 5, 2009
Roket Sanayii ve Ticaret AS, also known as Roketsan, which is based in the Turkish capital of Ankara, has agreed to a subcontracting deal with Raytheon to perform integration work and carry out testing on the control actuation system for the Patriot GEM-T missile for the United Arab Emirates. Roketsan will cooperate with other Raytheon subcontractors in Turkey and the United States to carry out the main assembly operations on the project at its main factory in Ankara. "The award recognizes the team for achieving a host of technology breakthroughs that have culminated in a fully integrated system with the advantages of speed-of-light destruction of ballistic missile threats from a highly mobile platform," the company said.







  • Twitter users not sticking around: Nielsen
  • SES Astra Expands Two-Way Satellite Broadband In Central And Eastern Europe
  • Google profit up but first quarterly revenue drop
  • US drawing up national broadband plan

  • Planck Mated With The Ariane 5 ECA Launcher
  • Base Considers Disassembling Historical Launch Complex
  • Continental Provides New Tires For Payload Transporter
  • NATO satellite launched on Russian-Ukrainian rocket

  • Faster Than The Speed Of Sound
  • China Eastern Airlines reports huge loss in 2008
  • Airlines fear failure of global climate talks
  • State takes control of China's first private airline: report

  • LEAPP Completes First Anchor Milestone
  • US Soldiers Using General Dynamics Warfighter Information Network
  • Second Advanced EHF Satellite Completes Environmental Testing
  • Raytheon Lands Army Contract To Improve Battlefield Networked Communications

  • Boeing Completes PDR For Tracking And Data Relay Satellite Series K-L
  • Making The Space Environment Safer For Civil And Commercial Users
  • Virtual mobility for disabled wins Second Life prize
  • New Book Highlights Success Stories In Satellite Systems

  • SOFIA Science Mission Operations Director Selected
  • Marshall Space Flight Center Director Retires
  • SES Announces Management Team For Combined SES AMERICOM-NEW SKIES Division
  • Rob Peckham Joins SpaceX As VP Of Business Development

  • Northern Ice Front Of Wilkins Ice Shelf Is Becoming Unstable
  • RISAT Begins Sending Images: ISRO
  • NASA's Earth Observatory: A Decade of Earth Science On Display
  • Satellites Show How Earth Moved During Italy Quake

  • Garmin Provides Navigation To Fairline
  • imov Messenger Adds Skyhook For Location
  • AT And T Enables School Districts To Track Bus Fleets And Boost Student Safety
  • NOAA Accepts ESRI-Based System To Modernize Nautical Chart Production

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2007 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement