Subscribe to our free daily newsletters
  Space Industry and Business News  

Subscribe to our free daily newsletters

Radiation protection expert criticizes comparison of Fukushima to Chernobyl

File image.
by Staff Writers
London, UK (SPX) May 24, 2011
In the opening editorial to the latest edition of the Journal of Radiological Protection, published, Wednesday 18 May, radiological protection expert Professor Richard Wakeford of the Dalton Nuclear Institute, The University of Manchester, gives a detailed account of events at Fukushima Dai-ichi Nuclear Power Station, and poses several questions that remain unanswered, several weeks on from the earthquake and tsunami on 11 March.

Taking a close look at information disclosed by Japanese government ministries, the World Health Organisation, the International Atomic Energy Agency and others, Professor Wakeford details events at the six different reactors, and the consequent releases of radioactivity.

While praising the organisational abilities of the Japanese authorities and the heroic efforts of emergency workers, Wakeford is critical of alarmist pronouncements from some of those in authority outside Japan, and offers perspective on the radiological hazard the emergency poses.

Professor Wakeford highlights a peculiarity of the International Nuclear and Radiological Event Scale (INES). The INES, designed to communicate to the public the severity of events at nuclear facilities, rather confusingly brackets Fukushima with Chernobyl as a Level 7 major accident, despite Fukushima only having released 10% of the radioactivity released by Chernobyl at the time the INES announcement was made.

Professor Wakeford explains, "Since Level 7 is the highest rating on INES there can be no distinction between the Fukushima and Chernobyl accidents, leading many to proclaim the Fukushima accident as 'another Chernobyl', which it is not....... A situation which has led to criticism of the INES."

Wakeford also highlights how lessons have been learnt since Chernobyl and have helped guide the actions taken by Japanese authorities, including the establishment of a 20km radius evacuation zone, banning the consumption of contaminated foodstuffs, issuing stable iodine tablets, and the monitoring of the thyroids of nearly 1,000 children in badly affected areas.

Professor Wakeford also compares the reality on the ground - sad but orderly evacuations and low level radiation risks among the most vulnerable - with the pronouncements from some of those in authority outside Japan which, Wakeford writes, "have been breathtaking in their extravagance."

"Gunther Oettinger, European Commissioner for Energy, was reported on 15 March as saying, 'There is talk of an apocalypse and I think the word is particularly well-chosen.' Such remarks could have triggered panic in Tokyo and flight on the roads south, which would almost certainly have caused accidents and deaths."

While the monitoring of radiation levels across and beyond Fukushima Prefecture, and among those most likely to be affected, has returned results more encouraging than much of the speculation would suggest, Wakeford does point to some serious ongoing concerns.

One difficult decision facing the Japanese authorities is when and if evacuees are allowed to return to their homes. This will be especially problematical in the sector to the north-west of the site that has been particularly badly affected, and measures are likely to be needed in certain areas to reduce radiation levels before people are permitted to live there permanently.

Another key concern is how authorities will contain and deal with the highly contaminated water that has been found to be present on the Fukushima site.

Many questions surrounding events in Fukushima remain unanswered, most hinging on whether emergency systems were adequate to meet foreseeable, even if unlikely, circumstances.

Professor Wakeford concludes, however, in admiration of Japanese courage, "Given the difficult background circumstances pertaining in Fukushima Prefecture as problems mounted at the Fukushima Dai-ichi NPS, the organisational abilities of the Japanese authorities in dealing with the evacuation, monitoring and protection of the public has to be admired.

In particular, the heroic efforts of the emergency workers, battling under conditions that were often atrocious, should not pass without respect and praise. I for one bow to their courage."

From Wednesday 18 May, Professor Richard Wakeford's editorial can be found at

Share This Article With Planet Earth DiggDigg RedditReddit
YahooMyWebYahooMyWeb GoogleGoogle FacebookFacebook

Related Links
Institute of Physics
Space Technology News - Applications and Research

Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News

Japanese protest revised school radiation limit
Tokyo (AFP) May 23, 2011
Furious parents at the centre of Japan's atomic crisis and hundreds of their supporters rallied in Tokyo Monday against revised nuclear safety standards in schools they say are putting children at risk. Japanese children can now be exposed to 20 times the radiation that was permissible before the March 11 tsunami caused a meltdown at the Fukushima nuclear plant, sparking the world's worst nu ... read more

World Record in Ultra-Rapid Data Transmission

Microsoft unveils Windows Phone update 'Mango'

Better buildings for extreme climates will be focus of researcher talk

Foxconn polishing plants in China closed after blast

Northrop Grumman Awarded Continuing Operation of Battlefield Airborne Communications Node Contract

ADTI Launches High Performance Antenna Arrays Protype Program

Northrop Grumman Awarded Contract to Develop EHF SatComms Antenna for B-2 Bomber

Lockheed Martin To Produce Equipment For US Army Tactical On-The-Move Network

Russia sends two Soyuz carrier rockets to French Guiana

ILS Proton Successfully Launches Telstar 14R And Estrela do Sul 2 for Telesat

Satellites for Asia and India are orbited on Arianespace's third Ariane 5 mission of 2011

Taiwan, Singapore launch satellite

Europe's first EGNOS airport to guide down giant Beluga aircraft

'Green' GPS saves fuel, energy

Apple update fixes iPhone tracking "bugs"

Russia, Sweden to boost space cooperation

Expert warns against 'experimenting' with flights in ashw/

Environmental Tectonics Forms Non-Profit NASTAR Foundation to Support Aerospace Industry

China Has Opportunity to Lead a Transformation in Air-Traffic Management

Solar plane makes 13-hour flight

Graphene optical modulators could lead to ultrafast communications

Pentagonal tiles pave the way towards organic electronics

NRL Scientists Achieve High Temperature Milestone in Silicon Spintronics

Intel chip breakthrough a boon for mobile gadgets

Satellites monitor Icelandic ash plume

NASA ocean-watch satellite ready for June launch

TerraSAR-X images Urban sprawl around Istanbul

Mapping the impact of a deadly mosquito

Europe may ban plastic bags

Falklands mines a running drain of funds

Indian government vows to pursue Bhopal case

India's top court refuses to reopen Bhopal case

The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2010 - SpaceDaily. AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement