Washington (AFP) March 4, 2011
A near-decade battle between two aerospace titans ended Friday as Europe's EADS said it would not contest rival Boeing's win of a $30 billion US Air Force tanker contract.
But in a parting shot after the controversy-marred fight for the huge aerial refuelers, EADS -- parent of Airbus -- said its competition had saved US taxpayers $16 billion, and questioned whether Boeing would make any money with its cut-price bid.
"EADS North America has decided not to protest," Ralph Crosby, chairman of the regional unit, said at a news conference in Washington.
"We determined that, one, the outcome was determined by the rules; two, there was no basis for protest," Crosby said.
After a lengthy contest that saw results scrubbed and the deal rebid twice, on February 24 the US Air Force awarded the $30-plus billion contract for up to 179 aerial refueling tankers to Boeing, calling the US bidder "a clear winner."
According to EADS, Boeing's bid was priced at $31.5 billion, while the EADS bid was 11 percent higher at $35 billion.
Under the terms of the process, a differential of more than one percent meant that price, and not other non-mandatory details in the two companies' proposals, would decide the contest.
EADS had the right to protest the decision with the Government Accountability Office within 10 days of the contract's award.
Crosby noted that the Defense Department had altered the requirements in the final request for proposal to focus on "mere replacement" of the aging Boeing tankers it currently runs rather than on "modernization."
"In the end, the tanker with the greatest capability wasn't selected," he said.
Allowing mid-air refueling of fights and bombers, the tankers are crucial in projecting the US military's power around the world.
Crosby said EADS had offered an "aggressive" price to win the contract, but that "this outcome was ordained by a very, very aggressive price from our competition."
The Air Force originally began discussing the deal with Boeing alone on a pricey leasing basis in 2001, a deal that sparked political controversy and eventually saw two key people involved jailed for corruption.
It was then turned into a competitive bid process which pitted home-grown Boeing against the European giant -- which argued it would build its jets inside the United States, adding American jobs rather than European ones.
That was not enough in the final deal, but EADS said it had saved US taxpayers $16 billion by competing against Boeing.
Asked whether Boeing chose to not make money in order to keep a competitor out of North America, Crosby said: "It is certainly a logical conclusion to draw from the decrease of the price. You have to ask Boeing what their strategy was."
Bill Barksdale, Boeing's tanker program spokesman, said that the company would deliver a "best value" aircraft.
"We are proud to have been selected to produce the most advanced, capable, and efficient next-generation aerial refueling tanker for the Air Force at the best value for the taxpayers," Barksdale said in an email interview.
"We understand the importance of this effort to our customer and the country and stand ready, along with our nationwide team of suppliers, to go to work on the new KC-46A program."
Commenting on Boeing's plan to test-fly its tanker in 2015, with delivery of the first 18 by 2017, Crosby highlighted that the EADS-Airbus tanker was already flying.
"We stand ready with a fully operative system if they fail" to deliver their tanker in time, he said.
Crosby said the Pentagon debriefing on the decision Monday was "very short."
"I think what the department decided ... was to give us what was sufficient to decide whether or not to protest," he said.
"We were given inadequate data, but that's a new paradigm."
EADS NA chief executive Sean O'Keefe said that the Defense Department determined the company was "a fully qualified prime contractor" and the competition had boosted its abilities to vie for US military contracts.
Boeing shares were down 1.34 percent at $70.75 in afternoon New York trade.
Share This Article With Planet Earth
Aerospace News at SpaceMart.com
US "air capital" savors Boeing tanker victory
Wichita, Kansas (AFP) Feb 24, 2011
On a day as cold and dreary as this US city's economy, residents were hoping against hope Thursday for good news. Shortly after the stock market closed, they got it. The US Air Force announced that Boeing had won a $30 billion contract for mid-air refuelers, beating out European Aeronautic Defence and Space Co, parent of Airbus. "We got it!" yelled an employee leaving the sprawling Boein ... read more
NIST Expert Software Lowers The Stress On Materials Problems|
New metals are moldable like plastic
In surprise appearance, Jobs unveils iPad 2
Eye-controlled laptop turns heads at high-tech fair
LockMart Wins Role On Navy C4ISR Services Contract
ONR Moves A Modular Space Communications Asset Into Unmanned Aircraft For Marines
Northrop Grumman Next-Gen FBCB2 System Approved For Fielding
Boeing To Demonstrate Aviation Command And Control Subsystem For US Marine Corps
NASA Assessing New Launch Dates For The Glory Mission
Successful Launch Of REXUS 9
24 hour delay for launch of NASA satellite
SpaceX to focus on astronaut capsule
ZST Digital Networks Signs Agreement To Develop City-Wide GPS Platform
Retail Mobile Systems Easily Tricked
MatchMaker OCR Solution By APS Technology Receives Patent
Lynden Transport Expands Service To And From Oklahoma And North Dakota
EADS will not protest Boeing tanker contract
US "air capital" savors Boeing tanker victory
China to spend $230 bn on aviation sector
Revolutionary Design For Stratospheric High Altitude Balloon Missions
New Generation Of Optical Integrated Devices For Future Quantum Computers
JQI Physicists Demonstrate Coveted Spin-Orbit Coupling In Atomic Gases
New MIT Developments In Quantum Computing
Development Team Achieves One Terabit per Second Data Rate On Single Integrated Photonic Chip
Good Progress On Troubleshooting
Ministerial Panel Deliberates Google's Planned Launch Of Street View
NASA Spacecraft Images New Zealand Quake Region
Earth's Core Rotating Faster Than Rest Of The Planet
Pollution a threat to China's growth
Russia jails four environmentalists after protest
Kenya, France seek new global environment body
Baby dolphins dying along oil-soaked US Gulf Coast
|The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2010 - SpaceDaily. AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement|